Skip to content

Archive for the ‘Mortgage, Lending, Refinance’ Category

Morgan Stanley’s Current State of the National Housing Market, December 2009

Thursday, December 3rd, 2009

This article – posted on Morgan Stanley’s investor website – is perhaps the most succinct analysis of the current state of the national housing market that I have read, in a while.

It breaks down and explains – with references and analysis – the primary areas of concern. While some of these areas are not anything new, Richard Berner (author) does a great job of pointing out the housing risks as well as the strong points through the end of 2009 and what to expect coming into 2010.

He warns of payback from the home-buyer tax credit (with scant reference to a smaller, similar situation back in 1975), rising unemployment, possible looming foreclosures being dumped on the market (shadow inventory), and builders competing with the current, sizable inventory of distressed properties.

However, on the positive side, rates are still low, affordability is much better and still improving, and inventory (although still higher than we’d like to see) is still trending lower, which is great.

More Details on Homebuyer $8,000 and $6,500 Tax Credit

Sunday, November 22nd, 2009

Please click here to see full details.

Minneapolis and Edina Housing Market Update for Week Ending 10/25/2009

Wednesday, October 28th, 2009

This video update from the Minneapolis Area Association of Realtors (MAAR) is a good snapshot of what is happening in our market right now. What it leaves out is what is happening at the upper price-brackets, which I’ll get to in a moment. Also, here is a basic market update on stats such as average days on market until a sale etc.

First: In the Minneapolis and St. Paul area real estate market, we are burning through our supply of foreclosures much faster than we are short sales and with good reason: Foreclosures are much easier to deal with than are short sales. Even though the foreclosure process is after the short sale process, the bank deals and replies to foreclosure offers (usually) in a much timelier manner than they do short sales. Right now our market inventory is  @ 2,000 foreclosure units – or about a 2.3 month supply. However, our short sale inventory is @ 4,200 units, which is about a 12.6 month supply (keeping in mind short sales sell less and take longer to sell).

Our housing market will never be in true recovery mode (as a whole) until we A) greatly reduce the existing short-sale and foreclosure (distressed property) inventory B) greatly reduce the potential distressed properties, C) Stabilize the employment sectors and D) See true, tenable signs of recovery in our economy in general. We will really have to let the distressed properties run their course and ‘burn-off’ the current supply and also the future supply (of which it appears there is still a fair amount coming down the pike).

Now does this mean it is doom and gloom in all areas of the our local or national real estate market? The answer is a definite no. As I’ve been saying all along, some micro-markets – at certain price points – within our local and national markets are still holding strong and steady.  Examples: Certain parts of Southwest Minneapolis ($175K-$350K) , Edina ($225K-$415K), St. Louis Park ($175K-$250K) and West Bloomington ($175K-$300K) have all had busy activity and strong sales.  Of course, the $8,000 home-buyer tax credit and low interest rates have been a great motivator, but these areas usually hold well anyhow.

Upper-bracket sales update: As is much the case nationwide, in general, in the twin-cities, there is a large inventory of upper-bracket homes on the market. In the twin cities metro, we currently have about a 35-month inventory @ $1-million and up. Now this does not mean that a home in the Edina Country Club, South Harriet Park, Parkwood Knolls, or in Kenwood, Lake of the Isles, Lowry Hill, Lynnhurst or Linden Hills will take 35 months to sell, by any means. As I’ve said, the inventory is a 35-month supply, and many areas do much better than others, such as Medina, or Plymouth for example.

One of the difficulties is getting past one great myth right now: the myth that jumbo (loans over $417K) are an expensive, poor product. The truth is, in the past couple of months, jumbo products have come around and been lowered to historically great rates again, and there are now products in which you do not have to do 20% down, and also not have to pay mortgage insurance!

Example 1: A 30-year fixed jumbo can be had for 5.75%.
Example 2: A jumbo, 15%-down option with no mortgage insurance (MI) can be had for 6.1% (as of last Friday).

This is fantastic news for upper-bracket, but the word has to get out there. Right now, in upper-bracket sales, many excellent deals can be had and money (lending) is cheap!

Minneapolis Star Tribune: Minneapolis Metro Housing Market Has Best National Gain in Home Prices

Wednesday, September 30th, 2009

As the Minneapolis Association of Area Realtors (MAAR) data has come in, and the Minneapolis Star Tribune is reporting in this article, the Twin Cities’ 4.6 percent rise in home prices in July was the best among the top 20 markets monitored by the Case-Shiller Index.

July 2009 was the largest month-to-month rise in home prices (over June) that we have seen in over a decade. July was the third consecutive monthly gain in the Minneapolis/St. Paul housing market.

The article goes on to point out how consumer confidence is closely tied to losses and gains in the housing market (I’m quite certain we’re all aware of this by now), and how the good news is somewhat relative, as even though we are currently up, August is a tougher month than July was, and that overall we are down a long ways from the very untenable highs we had 4 years ago.

More to be revealed…

Mortgage Matters: Current State Of The Housing Market, Our Economy And The Case-Schiller Index

Thursday, September 3rd, 2009

With the passing of each week it becomes increasingly difficult to argue that housing isn’t in full-recovery mode. This week’s data makes it nearly impossible, considering that sales of new homes spiked 9.6%, in July, to an annual pace of 433,000 units. The “experts” had expected sales to post at only 390,000 units. The increase was the largest since February 2005, helping to force the inventory of new homes down to a 7.5-month supply, the lowest in 16 years.
Even more encouraging, the most recalcitrant housing bear is starting to turn bullish. Robert Shiller, co-creator of the S&P/Case-Shiller home-price index, told Bloomberg that “we might be seeing a turnaround.” Understated, to be sure, but that’s Shiller’s style. As for his index, 18 of the 20 cities tracked showed improvement in June, up from eight in May, four in April, and only one in March.
Detractors will counter that the recovery is concentrated in lower-priced homes. True, but that’s changing as well. Toll Brothers, a luxury homebuilder, stated that declining cancellations and firming prices has allowed the company to reduce incentives and raise prices in selected communities. To quote Toll Brothers Chairman and CEO Robert Toll, “We believe that customers are recognizing that now is the time to get into the market to take advantage of near-record affordability in what is still, for now, a buyer’s market.”
More optimism can be gleaned from the fact that housing isn’t the only big-ticket sector showing signs of recovery. Orders for durable goods – those meant to last several years – jumped 4.9% in July, posting the biggest increase in two years. Yes, the “cash-for-clunkers” program was a contributing factor, but even without this incentive, other durable goods orders moved ahead 0.8%.
The gross domestic product numbers also suggest that all, if not well, is getting better. On that front, the government says the economy shrank at an annual rate of 1% in the second quarter, a better-than-expected showing. The drop, while representing a record fourth consecutive decline, was far smaller than the previous two quarters. It also was stronger than the 1.4% decline that many economists had expected.
Finally, mortgage rates continue to hold steady, a sign that inflation remains a non-issue. The 30-year fixed-rate loan continues to hold at 5.5% while the 15-year fixed-rate and five-year adjustable-rate loans continue to hold at around 4.9%. Today’s housing market remains a buyer’s market, with low prices and low borrowing rates, but keep in mind Mr. Toll’s quote, “for now.”

With the passing of each week it becomes increasingly difficult to argue that housing isn’t in full-recovery mode. This week’s data makes it nearly impossible, considering that sales of new homes spiked 9.6%, in July, to an annual pace of 433,000 units. The “experts” had expected sales to post at only 390,000 units. The increase was the largest since February 2005, helping to force the inventory of new homes down to a 7.5-month supply, the lowest in 16 years.

Even more encouraging, the most recalcitrant housing bear is starting to turn bullish. Robert Shiller, co-creator of the S&P/Case-Shiller home-price index, told Bloomberg that “we might be seeing a turnaround.” Understated, to be sure, but that’s Shiller’s style. As for his index, 18 of the 20 cities tracked showed improvement in June, up from eight in May, four in April, and only one in March.

Detractors will counter that the recovery is concentrated in lower-priced homes. True, but that’s changing as well. Toll Brothers, a luxury homebuilder, stated that declining cancellations and firming prices has allowed the company to reduce incentives and raise prices in selected communities. To quote Toll Brothers Chairman and CEO Robert Toll, “We believe that customers are recognizing that now is the time to get into the market to take advantage of near-record affordability in what is still, for now, a buyer’s market.”

More optimism can be gleaned from the fact that housing isn’t the only big-ticket sector showing signs of recovery. Orders for durable goods – those meant to last several years – jumped 4.9% in July, posting the biggest increase in two years. Yes, the “cash-for-clunkers” program was a contributing factor, but even without this incentive, other durable goods orders moved ahead 0.8%.

The gross domestic product numbers also suggest that all, if not well, is getting better. On that front, the government says the economy shrank at an annual rate of 1% in the second quarter, a better-than-expected showing. The drop, while representing a record fourth consecutive decline, was far smaller than the previous two quarters. It also was stronger than the 1.4% decline that many economists had expected.

Finally, mortgage rates continue to hold steady, a sign that inflation remains a non-issue. The 30-year fixed-rate loan continues to hold at 5.5% while the 15-year fixed-rate and five-year adjustable-rate loans continue to hold at around 4.9%. Today’s housing market remains a buyer’s market, with low prices and low borrowing rates, but keep in mind Mr. Toll’s quote, “for now.”

How Technology Helped Avert Disaster:

The economy was never going to get as bad as many had thought, and by many we mean the doomsayers predicting a replay of the 1930’s. Reason being, markets are too efficient and too knowledgeable today; many people are following all segments of the economy, thanks in large part to today’s information and communications technology.

A stock-market analogy is in order: Back in the 1930’s, Ben Graham, Warren Buffett’s mentor, discovered that buying stocks trading at dirt-cheap prices proved highly remunerative. Graham would parse financial statements for companies with a lot of cash and little debt – a tedious and time-consuming endeavor at the time. Graham’s modus was to buy companies for their current assets and get everything else – land, plant, and equipment – free. Graham’s strategy can’t be replicated today because information is so widely and cheaply disseminated that investors pounce before companies reach such levels.

Homes aren’t homogeneous like stocks, but there are many more information-savvy buyers vetting housing opportunities today than there were in the 1930’s, so prices – on the national level – are highly unlikely to collapse. (They can collapse in niche, depressed markets – inner-city Detroit, for example – but that’s always been the case.) Of course, there is always a risk of buying too soon, but buying too soon is still usually remunerative over the long run. The same can’t be said for buying too late.

*Disclaimer: This Newsletter is for informational purposes only. The information contained herein may not be applicable to every situation or jurisdiction and we urge you to consult your professional advisor prior to acting on information contained herein. The content, accuracy and opinions expressed herein are not verified or endorsed by the sponsor hereof.

Mortgage Matters is Courtesy of Lori Donnelly, Vice-President of Lending, M&I Bank, Minneapolis.
Direct: 612-904-8129
http://www.mibank.com/ldonnelly

Deutsche Bank Predicting Half of All Mortgages to be Underwater by 2011

Thursday, August 6th, 2009

Predictions on the condition of the mortgage market vary, sometimes greatly. In this article Deutsche Bank – one of the world’s leading powerhouse banking and investment institutions – is predicting that about half of all U.S. mortgages will be underwater (owing more than their home is worth) by the first quarter of 2011. This is to include ‘Prime’ loans as well, not just ’subprime.’

Whereas I can see the  possibility of this in certainly markets, this would not be a universal, across the board mortgage crisis. Some metro areas are in much better shape than others. For example: the Detroit and Las Vegas areas will be offsetting the curve a great deal (in the negative), while other areas such as the Minneapolis area housing market, or the Dallas and Salt Lake City Housing markets are in much better shape.

It will be quite interetsting to see how this plays out, and I certainly hope Deutsche Bank is wrong in their prognostication for early 2011.

My advice if you are buying a home in the Minneapolis area housing market: if you can (depending on your price-point), buy your next home in Southwest Minneapolis, Edina and sometimes West Bloomington areas.

First-Time Homebuyer Tax Credit to Expire: Buyer’s Must Close By November 30th

Thursday, July 30th, 2009

First-time homebuyers that have been putting off purchasing a home until the last minute will really need to start moving at this point. Considering that they will need to close by Novermber 30th, and that most lenders need 21-45 days to properly underwrite a loan, and for the buyer to have at least 3-7 business days to negotiate an offer and go through the inspection process, this puts the final date you’ll want to submit an offer somewhere between October 12th-November 5th. After that, it will be a very tight squeeze. Also, many loans have been snagging at the last minute, and closings have to go a second round, potentially pushing back the closing date even further (which is why it is very important to work with a reputable lender…I’ve suggested this, ad-nauseum and ad-infinitum).

This means that if you should be targeting and seeing homes with your realtor now, as the final target date (best-case, last-minute scenario) is only about 70 days from now, if you would like the free, $8000.00 from the fed, just for buying a home. This would be a sad tax credit (actual cash in pocket, not a deduction) to miss out on, if you have been seriously thinking of purchasing a home.

How would you like 8 of these $1,000.00 notes?1000-dollar-bill

Mortgage Matters Market Recap

Wednesday, July 15th, 2009

Many Americans extended their July 4 th holiday through last week, a precept reflected in the dearth of market data to hit the wires. But what did hit the wires was at least meaningful, if not insightful.
For instance, we’ve stated repeatedly in these missives that the real engine of change in the mortgage and housing market is the individual market participant (like us). Government can be a mitigating factor, to be sure, but nothing mitigates like the actions of individuals to get things moving in the right direction. Indeed, recent data from Clayton Holdings showed that recent government-supported foreclosure moratoriums had virtually no impact on stemming the foreclosure tide, which is much less of a tide today anyway.
Many pundits were predicting a second wave of foreclosures headed our way in the second half of the year, as banks tried to unload homes they can’t refinance. But for now, at least, the big wave of bank-owned properties appears to have crested. According to Foreclosures.com, foreclosures dropped 11% nationally in the second quarter of 2009 to 205,000 compared to 231,000 in the first quarter of 2009. Even more encouraging, June’s foreclosure numbers reached record lows for the year.
More good news on housing was dispensed by Clear Capital, which noted that for the first time since 2006, the nation posted positive quarter-over-quarter price returns in the second quarter of 2009, according to its July Home Data Index Report released last Thursday. Fueled by strong seasonal spring sales in the Midwest , which had a price increase of 5.3% over the first quarter of 2009, the overall U.S. price growth increased by 1.7%.
It’s obvious that people are buying more homes – foreclosures or otherwise. The Mortgage Bankers Association released its Weekly Mortgage Applications Survey for the week ending July 3, and new loan applications increased 10.9% from the previous week. Mortgage rates remain low, and are actually dropping. The benchmark 30-year, fixed-rate mortgage fell 11 basis points to average 5.59% last week, according to the Bankrate.com national survey of large lenders, while the benchmark 15-year, fixed-rate mortgage fell 14 basis points to average 4.93%. The drop should assuage concerns among many potential borrowers that they missed the boat.

The Truth of the Matter
An enlightening op-ed piece by Stan Liebowitz, University of Texas ( Dallas ) economics professor, appeared in the July 3 rd edition of the Wall Street Journal, vetting the mushrooming rate of mortgage foreclosures since 2007. What Liebowitz had to say supports the old adage that a lie can get half way around the world before the truth gets out of the gate.
In short, Liebowitz debunked the myth that subprime mortgage lenders fooled hapless borrowers into taking complex, low initial rate loans. He noted that the focus on subprimes ignores the widely available industry facts (reported by the Mortgage Bankers Association) that 51% of all foreclosed homes had prime loans, not subprime, and that the foreclosure rate for prime loans grew by 488% compared to a growth rate of 200% for subprime foreclosures.
Liebowitz also found that interest-rate resets did not measurably increase foreclosures until the reset was greater than four percentage points. Only 8% of foreclosures had an interest rate increase of that much. In a nutshell, the overall impact of upward interest rate resets was much smaller than the impact from reduction in homeowners’ equity.
The good news, according to Liebowitz, is the reduction in homeowners’ equity appears to be ending. He notes that housing prices are likely to stop falling soon (an opinion we’ve been forwarding the past few months), because current prices are approaching their long-term, inflation-adjusted pre-bubble level. In turn, a perceived, and very real, end to the drop in housing prices will only stimulate further activity.

- Courtesy of Lori Donnnelly, V.P. Mortgage Lending, M&I Bank, Minneapolis:
http://www.mibank.com/ldonnelly

Homes in Minneapolis: Update on Home Sales Activity

Friday, June 12th, 2009

More good news on the housing market front for the Minneapolis housing market: New listings are continually declining in our market, which is one of the keys to recovery. While there are many other factors, a glut of homes on the market is always detrimental. We are finally down in new listings for the entire year, after a continual increase during the previous 7 years. 1,566 homes went on the market last week, vs. 1,752 during this same week, last year. Our peak week this year was week ending 05/09, with 2,058 (the comparable peak week the year prior was 2,380 new listings). So we are down -10.6% in new listings this week over last year. As our Minneapolis/St. Paul housing market has seen this trend for the entire year, I believe this is encouraging news. 

Our supply vs. demand ratio for 06/09  has also come down to 5.04 homes for every active home-buyer, compared with 1 year ago in June 2008, when we had 7.57 homes for every active home-buyer.

Let’s hope this trend continues.

Minneapolis housing market activity for week 05/26/2009

Thursday, May 28th, 2009

As of May 26th, the Minneapolis metro housing market (12-county) inventory is down (to 23,855) from this point last year (27,358), pending sales up are (12,750) up from this point last year (10,296), with the Minneapolis housing market overall average of days on market until a sale down from this point last year, from 154, to 150. Also, the percent of list price received at sale is down 1.7% from this point last year, from 31.7%, to 90.0%.

In general, these are good signs for the Minneapolis housing market. However, with the very quick, recent spike in interest rates, we could be slowing our momentum in a very fragile housing recovery. More to be revealed…